Devoir de Philosophie

The Varieties of the Millennial Experience

Publié le 21/11/2011

Extrait du document

experience

DOCUMENT DE 23 PAGES

In order to understand millennial beliefs and their apocalyptic movements, we must become familiar with their fundamental tensions. What I offer here below is a typology of millennial and apocalyptic types.  This typology, however, represents only a static view of the phenomenon. Nothing takes shape and mutates faster over (apocalyptic) time than a millennial movement which can go from waxing enthusiasm to devastating disappointment in a matter of days, months, at most years.  In order, then, to illustrate how these varieties can appear and mutate within a single movement, I will use the example of one of the religious movements whose apocalyptic and millennial dimensions are relatively unknown.

 

Eschatology: This notion holds that at the end (eschaton) of “time”, the Lord will judge the quick and the dead, all, together, publicly.  This apocalyptic theodicy can give birth to two possible aftermaths:

1)      an eschatological (final) one in which the earthly world is consumed in purifying fires and rewards in heaven and punishments in hell are final.

2)      a millennial one in which the new world of justice appears on earth and marks a messianic age of abundance and the joy of fellowship. 

 

There are, of course, both religious and secular variants of eschatology.  If God does not bring his creation to an end, the universe may, in the form, for example, of comets colliding with earth.[1]  Even more attractive are the profoundly moralistic warnings against self-destruction by nuclear or other weapons of mass destruction, or by irreversible human-induced ecological destruction that threatens the very existence of the human race – or certainly “the world as we know it.”


[1][1] The role of “apocalyptic time” in activating eschatological concerns comes out in the famous anecdote of the astronomer who, after lecturing on how the sun will eventually go nova, burning the earth up, was asked how long until that will happen.  “Five billion years,” be replied.  “Oh,” said the questioner, “thank goodness.  I thought you said five million.”

experience

« I.1 Varieties 2 Resurrection of the Dead ( al-Qiy āma ) and the Day of Judgment ( Yawm al-H i s āb) are at hand. 4 Eschatological thought tends towards totalism: the conclusion is final and decisive, a closed solution.

The messiness of earthly existence must itself burn up in the process.

This vision of a f inal and ultimate solution welcomes zero -sum thinking (dualistic), imagining a closed form of redemption: the good in heaven, the evil in hell; the body and all its disorderly delights are gone, permanently.

Tertullian’s vision of a heaven where the saved got to watch the torments of the damned in all their locations in Hell (which later inspired Dante to visionary poetry) may well represent a high -water mark in millennial resentment, 5 but it also illustrates the workings of closed images of redemption, in which the saved delight in the punishments of the damned.

When the body and soul are separated, the very drama of moral existence has been resolved, the real final solution .

There is no future, no more tests, no more hopes.

Future generations and the open -ended directions in which they might move no longer have a say in the redemptive process.

For the apocalyptic eschatological thinker, this is the End.

Millennialism: The millennial option moves in the opposite direction in its quest for theodicy; i t looks for justice in this world .

This option is an open challenge to the narrative that says everybody is morally corrupt, no real change is possible, and this is how things have to be.

Here saints will transform this world by transforming society, it will bring about a time of justice here on earth .

Thus millennialism is a form of social mysticism that is deeply politically subversive.

Thus in this essay, I use the term millennial to designate the belief that at some point in the future the world t hat we live in will be radically transformed into one of perfection – of peace, justice, fellowship and plenty.

This can, but need not, entail a belief in God.

The earliest recorded millennial movements all have invoked God; but, possibly as early as anc ient Greece, and with increasing frequency in the course of the last half millennium (1500 -2000 CE), the West has produced and exported a number of secular, indeed atheistic forms of millennialism.

Marx’s vision of the future, for example fits all the cri teria for demotic millennialism – from the vision of a non- coercive society (withering away of the state), to the dignity of manual labor (workers of the world), to the radical egalitarianism (renunciation of private property), to the fascination with the historical signs indicating the imminent apocalypse (historical dialectic). 6 Some historians object to maintaining so capacious a definition for millennialism, and suspect that it is merely a ploy for claiming a whole range of subject, and comes down to including virtually every radical movement in history within the purview of millennial 4 5 And the opposite of Origen’s heretical notion that even Satan himself, a fortiori all people, will eventually be saved.

6 On Marx, see chap.

11 of my book.. »

↓↓↓ APERÇU DU DOCUMENT ↓↓↓

Liens utiles