Devoir de Philosophie

Bauer, Bruno

Publié le 22/02/2012

Extrait du document

The career of the Hegelian theologian Bruno Bauer is marked by his sudden turn from a reasoned defender of Christianity into one of its most extreme critics. His radical interpretation of Hegel's philosophy, which he first used to defend orthodox biblical hermeneutics, ultimately led him to become, as one of his admirers said, the ‘Robespierre of theology'. As the leader of the so-called ‘Young Hegelian' school, Bauer was one of Hegel's most gifted students. However, his condemnation of theology in general and his thesis that the New Testament was merely the fictional product of an unknown author contributed to the general distrust of Hegelianism among religious thinkers. Although his many theological and historical writings now remain largely unread, his ‘Critical Philosophy' and his radical atheism exerted a strong influence upon Marx, who was his student and friend, and is still evident in such contemporaries as Jürgen Habermas.

« Bauer's efforts to treat the Gospel stories as the unconscious expressions of the religious mind, and to trace their historical development.

By 1840, he had written a number of multi-volume studies devoted to explaining that biblical history was fundamentally an imaginative exercise of the religious mind, with little or no actual basis in fact.

This thesis was set forth in his Kritik der evangelischen Geschichte des Johannes (Critique of the Gospel of John) .

From this point on, Bauer would identify his own position as that of ‘critic' and would term his philosophy ‘criticism' . By the end of June 1840, Bauer began another major study of the gospels, the three-volume Kritik der evangelischen Geschichte der Synoptiker (Critique of the Synoptic Gospels) .

In this work the problem of whether or not Jesus was in fact a historical figure was finally resolved: ‘To the question of whether Jesus was an authentic historical figure we replied that everything relating to the historical Jesus, all that we know of him, relates to the world of fancy, to be more exact - to Christian fancies.

This has no connection with any man who lived in the real world' .

In the autumn of 1840, Bauer concluded the writing of Die Posaune des jüngsten Gerichts über Hegel den Atheisten und Antichristen: Ein Ultimatum (The Trumpet of the Last Judgement Against Hegel the Atheist and Antichrist: An Ultimatum) .

This anonymous work was to rally all the various interpreters of Hegel into one camp from which they could enter into what he termed ‘The Campaign of Pure Criticism' .

It asserted that the prudent ‘Old Hegelians' associated with German academic life had consciously concealed the total incompatibility of Hegelian philosophy with traditional Christian belief and conservative political order. In the early 1840s Bauer was the leader of Berlin's notorious club, ‘The Free Ones' .

This group was the focal point of the radical ‘Young Hegelians' - a forum for the discussion of atheism and radical politics.

Among the participants were his own brother Edgar, the young Friedrich Engels, and a new friend, the radical individualist Max Stirner .

However, by 1844, Bauer's theoretical and theological concerns were rapidly losing their importance among the radical Hegelians, as they were becoming more concerned with applying their theory towards the practical overthrow of the reactionary forces controlling German political life.

Concerned with revolutionary deeds, and preparing for the establishment of a new democratic order, the new generation of radicals rejected Bauer's speculative ‘Terrorism of Pure Theory' .

Within a few years, Bauer's influence upon such revolutionary Hegelians as Marx and Engels came to a end. 2 Later years In 1843, Bauer wrote Das Entdeckte Christentum (Christianity Exposed) , a work intended to bring about a general appreciation of atheism through a rough dissection of Christian attitudes.

His belief that the Enlightenment and its ‘Age of Reason' embodied his Hegelian trust in the rationality of the real occasioned his next project, the four-volume Geschichte der Politik, Cultur und Aufklärung des achtzehnten Jahrhunderts (History of the Politics, Culture and Enlightenment of the Eighteenth Century) .

In 1846, having concluded his final volume, he continued. »

↓↓↓ APERÇU DU DOCUMENT ↓↓↓

Liens utiles